Skip to main content

The Case Against Advocating Small Government

 Small government is a term that I see used far too often. When a question of government comes up, smaller is the answer and I find that this is advocation of nothing good. Do I want a small government? Yes, but it’s not a position to advocate. This will be a relatively short topic as this is a pet peeve for me.

My big issue is that small government isn’t really a position, other than smaller. When people use this term they don’t literally mean smaller government. Today, the size of government is relatively large, so of course smaller is the goal. But this doesn’t answer how small the government should be. Where is the limit? What should a small government be doing? These positions, the more important positions, are left undefined. I’ve personally seen people advocating very stupid positions because smaller is better.

Limited Government

Here’s the big difference; advocating for something rather than some abstract view like smaller government creates understanding. When one talks of limited government they aren’t advocating smaller government; they’re advocating the specific role and boundaries of government.

These roles/boundaries will most likely result in a smaller government, but the goal isn’t to make government small. When the question of how big should the government be? Well, the answer is simply, as big as it needs to be to do it’s job.

In conclusion, advocate the role and boundaries of government, rather than some abstract idea of always being smaller. Smaller isn’t a meaningful position - but a well defined government is something meaningful, understood and more worthy of winning over people in discussions.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The West is Weak: Russia Invades Ukraine

 I haven't been writing a lot lately on this blog, but I felt the need to sign in and write about this. I've found myself feeling a bit depressed about the invasion of Ukraine - not because it happened, but due to how the west will predictably react to it. There will be a lot of talk, strong words, and even stronger rhetoric, but when the actual words become policy - it will be pathetically weak. There are people out there that seem to think or at least try to force the narrative of a simple dichotomy: either we accept Putin is doing it or it's WW3. Any normal person would find the choices here to be nauseating either way. If history is to serve a lesson, the first option often leads to the second option. But this dichotomy really illustrates the parameter that most people don't pick up on. The West is Morally Weak The facts are on the ground. The United States has the largest armed forces in human existence. A coalition of western powers is devastatingly more powerful

The Energy Market with Unreliables

 The energy market is going to be something that will be on people's minds for a long time because right now there is very poor policy and ideological views driving us to a crisis. There has been a nice little bull run going on over the last few months, and this may not be the crisis. It's something that may immerge here, but it might be 5-10 years from now. For the longest time I've been a passive index investor , and I still am for a nice chunk of my portfolio, but over the last 18 months I've decided that I'm going to apply my own judgment to the market place and invest accordingly. Over this time I've accumulated a pretty sizeable portfolio of LNG (Liquified Natural Gas) companies, in particular upstream and midstream companies. Renewable Energy or Green Energy are Unreliables There is a political push for green energy. It's driven by the moral ideas that green energy is this universally good  energy and all the other reliable energies we use like fossil

The Power of the Dog is Awful

I'm trying to post more personal things to this blog and I thought after what I finished watching last night - this was a good post to start. I often think that there is something wrong with me; like a horrible cynic. I like to watch entertaining movies and television, but everything I find lately is just awful. And it's almost like this never-ending cycle of bad to worse. It's not like I'm just watching straight to video movies or anything, I'm watching highly awarded and often praised as the hot thing on Netflix. Last night I watched The Power of the Dog (2021) . A highly regarded movie with a lot of nominations for various awards and I've heard a lot of talk about it - so I watch it. I don't want to spoil the movie for you, but absolutely nothing happens in this movie. There is a point in a movie where you just keep watching to see if anything happens and determine what exactly your time accomplished. Well, I can let you know that watching to the end will